Okay, I’m running short on time, I need to get this week’s pizza post over and that can mean only one thing: Gas Station Pizza!
I’ve felt bad about the score I gave Casey’s on Farmington Road. I’ve always felt that their pizza is pretty good for gas station pizza and I felt I just hit them on an off day.
So I’ve decided to give them another try at their other location off of Route 91 near the Shoppes At Grand Prairie.
And so it’s off we go!
Here we are at this North-side location of Casey’s General Store. As you can see, they feature their pizza on signs outside of their store. So let’s go in and give their pizza a second chance.
Wow, it’s pretty big in here, now we need to find…
The pizza rack! And Bingo here we are!
Okay, these slices look better than the Farmington Road experience.
I wrapped up the slice, paid for it and decided to eat it at the counter over here. There’s no one in the store and I preferred eating it here as opposed to the cold car.
They didn’t have plain cheese, so I got a pepperonie and sausage slice.
Okay, this is a lot better than the Farmington Road Slice.
It’s fresh and has a nice flavor to it. The crust isn’t as crispy as I like it, but it’s pretty good for a gas station slice of pizza!
For a dessert treat I got this French Sweetie Roll. It looked intriguing and I’ve never had a a French pastry in a gas station before.
Well, it was stale and dry and really sucked. Fuck this France pastry treat. The lesson learned today is that Casey’s deserves a second chance as far as gas station pizza goes, but fuck the French pastries. I should’ve just gotten one of their donuts.
——
THIS WEEK’S PIZZA RATING
I’ll give their pizza slice a 5.9, which is a good score for a gas station pizza slice. Not the best pizza in the world, but pretty good for a gas station slice!
——
THE PIZZA RATING LIST
Agatucci’s: 9.6
Weaver’s Fresh Food & Drink: 9.6
Rizzi’s Italian Restaurant: 9.6
Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North: 9.6
Peoria Pizza Works: 9.5
Slice: 9.4
The Red Barn (Butch’s Pizza): 9.2
Fat Jack’s: 8.7
Knuckles Pizza: 8.2
460° Pizza: 8.1
The Pour House: 8.1
Double A’s • Pizza • Sports Bar & Grill: 7.9
Rhythm Kitchen And Music Cafe: 7.8
Bullpen Bar & Grill: 7.4
Hoop’s Pub & Pizza: 7.4
The Fieldhouse Bar & Grill: 7.3
Monical’s: 7.3
Mr. Dough: 7.3
Old Chicago Pizza & Taproom: 7.1
The Owl’s Nest: 6.9
Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza: 6.9
Papa John’s: 6.7
HyVee Food Court: 6.6
Casey’s General Store (Off Of Route 91): 5.9
Pizza Hut: 5.8
Domino’s: 5.2
Huck’s: 4.9
Casey’s General Store (On Farmington Road): 3.3
Circle K: 0.1
——
Related Posts: Slices Of Peoria: The Bullpen Bar & Grill, Rhythm Kitchen, Circle K, Oliver’s Pizza and Pub North, Double A’s • Pizza • Sports Bar & Grill, Rizzi’s, The Red Barn, Hucks, The Pour House, Mr. Dough, The Owl’s Nest, Slice @ WeaverRidge, Brienzo’s Wood-Fired Pizza, 460° Pizza, HyVee Food Court, Domino’s, The Fieldhouse Bar & Grill, Casey’s General Store, Knuckles Pizza, Papa John’s, Weaver’s Fresh Food & Drink, Old Chicago Pizza & Taproom, Pizza Hut, Peoria Pizza Works, Monicals, Fat Jack’s Pizza, Hoops Pub & Pizza and Agatucci’s.